Shipping Carrier Insurance vs. U-PIC: Which One’s Right for Your Business?

Posted on October 15, 2025, by Matt Morelli

Shipping insurance is one of those things you don’t really think about - until you need it. Whether you're shipping something fragile, expensive, or just want peace of mind, choosing the right coverage matters. So how do you decide between the default shipping carrier insurance and a third-party option like U-PIC Shipping Insurance? Let’s break it down to see which option makes the most sense for your business and your budget.

Image: Delivery worker moving boxes in front of a truck with a shield and checkmark symbol representing insured and protected shipments.

What’s the Deal with Shipping Carrier Insurance?

You know how it goes - you're checking out online, and there’s that little box that offers shipping insurance from your carrier (think UPS, FedEx, or USPS). Seems easy enough, right? Just tick the box and boom, your package is insured.

Here’s how it works:

  • UPS and FedEx - typically cover packages valued up to $100 automatically. If your stuff is worth more than that, you’ll need to declare the value and pay for extra coverage.
  • USPS - throws in some basic coverage with their Priority Mail, but anything beyond that, and you’re paying extra.

Sounds simple, but there are some downsides you might want to consider.

Why It Might Be Enough:
  • It’s Convenient: You don’t have to do much. Carrier insurance is already part of the process, and you can easily add coverage while printing labels.
  • Basic Coverage: For lower-value shipments (under $100), this might be enough without extra hassle.
But Here’s the Catch:
  • It Gets Pricey: Shipping something more valuable? The cost of additional coverage can rack up quickly, especially for high-value items.
  • Slow Claims Process: If you’ve ever filed a claim with a carrier, you know it can be a waiting game. Weeks, sometimes even months, to get your money back.
  • Not Always Flexible: Certain items might not be covered, and getting reimbursed for damaged goods can feel like pulling teeth.

So, while carrier insurance is fine for quick, small orders, it’s not always the best choice when you’re dealing with more valuable or fragile items. That’s where U-PIC comes in.

Why U-PIC is a Game-Changer

U-PIC is a third-party shipping insurance provider that’s all about offering better rates and more flexibility. If you’re tired of the high costs and slow claims processes with carrier insurance, U-PIC gives you another option.

Why You’ll Love U-PIC:
  • Save Some Cash: Compared to carrier insurance, U-PIC can save you up to 90%. Yep, you read that right. Lower rates, especially for higher-value items.
  • Faster Claims: Don’t want to wait weeks for a claim to process? U-PIC handles claims fast - usually within 7 to 10 days. That’s a relief when you’re dealing with lost or damaged goods.
  • Customizable Coverage: Got special shipping needs? U-PIC covers a broader range of items, from fragile products to electronics, and you can tweak your policy to fit your business.
  • One-Stop-Shop: Whether you ship with USPS, FedEx, UPS, or a mix of carriers, U-PIC’s insurance works with all of them. No need to juggle different policies.
The Only Downside:
  • It’s Separate: You’ll need to set up your U-PIC policy separately from the carrier’s process. But with easy integrations for most eCommerce platforms, setup only takes minutes.
What’s the Bottom Line?

Let’s get real - if you’re shipping low-value stuff every once in a while, the carrier insurance might be all you need. But, if you’re shipping regularly, dealing with high-value products, or want to save on costs, U-PIC is the better option. You’ll get cheaper rates, faster claims, and the flexibility to cover whatever you’re shipping.

Ready to protect your shipments and your profits? Apply now to see how much you can save with U-PIC Shipping Insurance.

Quick Apply for Coverage with U-PIC

Save 50%–90% on shipping insurance today.
Complete the form, and our team will reach out to customize your coverage.